| 2006 - Turkey Bowl VII |
| Round | Team Hart | Team Cottom |
| 1 | 1. Laughlin, Tony | 2. Bucella, Tuna |
| 2 | 3. Marcelli, Matt | 4. Marcelli, Mark |
| 3 | 5. Pohlig, Bill | 6. Dougherty, Tim |
| 4 | 7. DiNofia, Rich | 8. Crooks, Chris |
| 5 | 9. Orio, Tom | 10. Trill, Mike |
| 6 | 11. Doubet, Joe | 12. Kelly, Sean |
| 2007 - Turkey Bowl VIII |
| Round | Team Derek | Team Rayer |
| 1 | 1. Marcelli, Matt | 2. Middleton, Paul |
| 2 | 4. Laughlin, Tony | 3. Cottom, Keith* |
| 3 | 6. Bucella, Tuna | 5. Marcelli, Mark |
| 4 | 8. Trill, Mike* | 7. Crooks, Chris |
| 5 | 10. DiNofia, Rich | 9. Dougherty, Tim* |
| 6 | 12. Hart, John* | 11. Pohlig, Bill |
| 7 | 14. Kelly, Sean | 13. Orio, Tom |
| * Traded |
| 2008 - Turkey Bowl IX |
| Round | Team Doc | Team Trill |
| 1 | 1. Detweiler, Derek | 2. Cottom, Keith |
| 2 | 4. Bucella, Tuna | 3. Tony Laughlin |
| 3 | 6. Middleton, Paul | 5. Marcelli, Matt |
| 4 | 8. Marcelli, Mark | 7. Hart, Jon |
| 5 | 10. DiNofia, Rich | 9. Rayer, Kevin |
| 6 | 12. Hart, Ian | 11. Crooks, Chris |
| 7 | 14. Pohlig, Bill | 13. Kelly, Sean |
| 8 | 16. Orio, Tom | 15. Doubet, Joe |
| 2010 - Turkey Bowl XI |
| Round | Team Doc | Team Trill |
| 1 | 1. Detweiler, Derek | 2. Cottom, Keith |
| 2 | 4. Bucella, Tuna | 3. Tony Laughlin |
| 3 | 6. Middleton, Paul | 5. Marcelli, Matt |
| 4 | 8. Marcelli, Mark | 7. Hart, Jon |
| 5 | 10. DiNofia, Rich | 9. Rayer, Kevin |
| 6 | 12. Hart, Ian | 11. Crooks, Chris |
| 7 | 14. Pohlig, Bill | 13. Kelly, Sean |
| 8 | 16. Orio, Tom | 15. Doubet, Joe |
| 2011 - Turkey Bowl XII |
| Round | Team Mark | Team Ian |
| 1 | 1. Dougherty, Tim | 2. Trill, Mike |
| 2 | 4. Rayer, Kevin | 3. Cottom, Keith |
| 3 | 6. Marcelli, Matt | 5. Middleton, Paul |
| 4 | 8. Buccella, Tuna | 7. Laughlin, Tony |
| 5 | 10. Pohlig, Bill | 9. Orio, Tom |
| 6 | 12. Dinofia, Rich | 11. Crooks, Chris |
| 7 | | 13. Kelly, Sean |
| 2012 - Turkey Bowl XIII |
| Round | Team Orio | Team Crooks |
| 1 | 1. Middleton, Paul | 2. Dougherty, Tim |
| 2 | 4. Rayer, Kevin | 3. Trill, Mike |
| 3 | 6. Marcelli, Matt | 5. Hart, Ian |
| 4 | 8. Marcelli, Mark | 7. Cottom, Keith |
| 5 | 10. Simcox, Joe | 9. Dinofia, Rich |
| 6 | | 11. Kelly, Sean |
| 2013 - Turkey Bowl XIV |
| Round | Team Doc | Team Trill |
| 1 | 1. Rayer, Kevin | 2. Middleton, Paul |
| 2 | 4. Marcelli, Mark | 3. Cottom, Keith |
| 3 | 6. Marcelli, Matt | 5. Orio, Rob |
| 4 | 8. Orio, Tom | 7. Crooks, Chris |
| 5 | 10. Kelly, Sean | 9. Dinofia, Rich |
| 6 | | 11. Simcox, Joe |
| 2014 - Turkey Bowl XV |
| Round | Team Mark | Team Matt |
| 1 | 1. Middleton, Paul | 2. Orio, Rob |
| 2 | 4. Trill, Mike | 3. Dougherty, Tim |
| 3 | 6. Cottom, Keith | 5. Crooks, Chris |
| 4 | 8. Conn, Kris | 7. Dinofia, Rich |
| 5 | 10. Kelly, Sean | 9. Orio, Tom |
| 6 | 12. Tomczuk, Steve | 11. Stagg, Christian |
| 2015 - Turkey Bowl XVI |
| Round | Team Dinofia | Team Crooks |
| 1 | 1. Trill, Mike | 2. Dougherty, Tim |
| 2 | 4. Middleton, Paul | 3. Cottom, Keith |
| 3 | 6. Conn, Kris | 5. Stagg, Christian |
| 4 | 8. Marcelli, Mark | 7. Marcelli, Matt |
| 5 | 10. Graff, Sean | 9. Orio, Tom |
| 6 | 12. Kelly, Sean | 11. Tomczuk, Steve |
|
|
|
